Hospitals and physician practices are increasingly affected by an overwhelming number of payer denials without basis. Initially these denials affected primarily physician billing, but of late they have expanded to the facility portion of the ED charge and present growing challenges for hospitals struggling to staff their RCM departments to handle the constantly increasing numbers.
When attempting to manage denials, a general "roadmap" can be effective to address the details supporting provider selection of charge codes. A review of the best content elements can assist in providing payers with undeniable support for the services rendered.
Content of Facility Coding Criteria
The Federal Register (Vol. 68, No. 155, p. 63461) outlined the Medicare conditions for charging the Facility component of an ED visit, noting that CPT codes "are defined to reflect only the activities of physicians" and are "inadequate to describe the range and mix of services provided by the hospital to patients in the clinic and emergency department settings (for example, ongoing nursing care, preparation for diagnostic tests and patient education)." This establishes the need for separate identification of ED Facility leveling, distinct from professional E/M leveling.
In the April 7, 2000 final rule (65 FR 18434), CMS gave each facility the responsibility to create an internal set of guidelines to determine the visit (E/M) level for each patient. Those guidelines must meet the following criteria:
- Coding guidelines should be based on emergency department or clinic facility resource use, rather than physician resource use.
- Coding guidelines should be clear, facilitate accurate payment, be usable for compliance purposes and audits, and comply with HIPAA.
- Coding guidelines should only require documentation that is clinically necessary for patient care.
- Coding guidelines should not create incentives for inappropriate coding.
The American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) developed an ED facility coding criteria currently in use at a majority of U.S. hospitals. However, payers often utilize proprietary facility coding criteria to approve or deny ED claims without sharing that information with participating providers, making it increasingly difficult to identify why payment for claims is downcoded or denied.
Medical Necessity
It is not uncommon to see claims downcoded for lack of medical necessity, a subjective concept payers can use to downcode or deny payment. CMS allows its Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) to determine whether services are reasonable and necessary. MACs use the following criteria:
- It is safe and effective.
- It is not experimental or investigational.
- It is appropriate when: furnished in accordance with accepted standards of medical practice; furnished in a setting appropriate to the medical needs and condition; ordered and furnished by qualified personnel; and meets the medical need of the patient.
EMTALA: The Framework You Cannot Ignore
Congress enacted the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) in 1986 to ensure public access to emergency services regardless of a patient's ability to pay. Section 1867 of the Social Security Act imposes specific obligations on Medicare-participating hospitals to provide a medical screening examination (MSE) when a request is made for examination or treatment of an emergency medical condition (EMC).
Many insurance plans are currently retrospectively denying claims by basing the determination of an emergency on a patient's final diagnosis rather than the presenting problems and symptoms. This is in direct conflict with EMTALA, which requires at least a medical screening exam, including diagnostic studies, until a medical emergency has been ruled out.
Outlining a Denial Reconsideration
When building a reconsideration request for a denied ED facility claim, include the following components:
- Summarize the reason for the reconsideration request by outlining how the originally billed code met the requirements, what conditions and treatments were primary and why.
- Restate the patient demographic information and reason for visit.
- Restate major patient past medical history that may be relevant to the current presentation.
- Discuss the physician's major findings from physical examination.
- Detail the differential diagnosis and establish how it affected the ordering of diagnostic studies and medications.
- Provide a brief description of the course of treatment in the ED, focusing on any problems, modifications to medications, and patient response to treatment.
- Discuss how treatment meets the standards of practice for the problems being addressed.
- Summarize any findings and discussions with other providers, noting their impressions and specialty.
- Discuss any documented nursing notes, cautions, concerns, patient responses to treatment, changes in therapy, and family concerns.
- Provide discussion of discharge orders, disposition, and any limitations on care provision.
- If pertinent, discuss chief complaint and presenting problems versus final diagnosis.
- If available, compare to information on other claims that resulted in payment and stress inconsistencies in the payer's decision making.
Managing facility coding denials requires both technical knowledge and persistence. Contact our team to learn how Edelberg & Associates can support your denials management program.
Get insights like this in your inbox. No spam, ever.
Emergency medicine coding updates, payer news, and compliance guidance delivered directly to revenue cycle leaders.
